Aboriginal Issues

The First Nations of the land now called Canada have faced considerable hardship and deprivation that are only beginning to be redressed through the political system. On this page, you will find links to facts about the Aboriginal population of Canada, Native organizations, treaties, and other legal sources, as well as to self-government proposals.

Indian and Northern Affairs Canada has posted a collection of facts about Canada's Aboriginal population and a range of publications available on-line,  which also include Registered Indian Population by Sex and Residence 2003 and profiles of all the individual First Nations. The Library of Parliament has a useful research paper on Indian Status and Band Membership Issues. Statistics Canada provides a range of data about the Aboriginal population, taken from the 1996 Census

Much important work is conducted by the Indian Claims Commission, which oversees a wide variety of land claims, known as "specific claims," across the country. 

The Report of the Royal Commission on Aboriginal People presents some useful information and perspectives on the history and current conditions of the Aboriginal peoples; see particularly Volume One. Many other recommendations for reform are contained in the other volumes. The federal government's response to the report is called Gathering Strength

To remain up-to-date on Aboriginal affairs, connect to Yahoo Canada's First Nations news site. 

Environics conducted a survey of Canadian attitudes on First Nations issues in 1998.  

ABORIGINAL SELF-GOVERNMENT

Considerable attention has been paid in the last decade to developing proposals for Aboriginal self-government. In cooperation with a number of First Nations, the federal government has signed a number of self-government agreements and set up a self-government pilot projects across the country. Visit the First Nations Governance Centre for a number of studies about self-government issues, including a paper by Maria Morellato on The Existence of Aboriginal Governance Rights within the Canadian Legal System (pdf).

For an overview of some self-government issues, see Aboriginal Self-Government, a 1995 INAC policy paper. The Library of Parliament's research paper on self-government is also useful reading. Several approaches to self-government have emerged:  Dismantling the Manitoba Region of the Department of Indian Affairs and Northern Development - an INAC initiative to provide Manitoba Bands with administrative autonomy

Self-Government Sechelt Style - municipal-model self-government for the Sechelt Nation 

The 1998 Nisga'a Treaty creates a new level of Aboriginal government for the Nisga'a Nation in B.C., whose laws in certain areas will have paramountcy over both federal and provincial laws. While this model has raised some controversy in British Columbia, it is not unlike other self-government agreements signed in recent years. For example, see Yukon First Nations Self-Government Act (1994). In some respects, this is similar to the proposals in the Charlottetown Accord, which would have established a new constitutionally entrenched order of government. The Nisga'a Treaty has engendered a lively debate over its desirability and constitutionality.  For more information on different points of view, visit: 

Another model - public government - has been adopted to settle self-government claims by the Innu in what is now the Northwest Territories. A new territorial government - Nunavut - came into being in 1999 and is formed from the eastern half of the N.W.T. This public model of Aboriginal self-government will allow all who live in the territory to participate in the government; however, the government will be controlled by Aboriginals since they compose the majority of the population. For more information on Nunavut, see the Nunavut Planning Commission Transition Team. You can also read the Nunavut Act passed by the Parliament of Canada to provide the framework for the territory's creation. 

An ongoing issue in Aboriginal politics is how to accommodate First Nations people who live in urban areas. INAC has released a report on Models for Aboriginal Government in Urban Areas. You can read more about this topic in a conference report, Aboriginal Governance in Urban Settings: Completing the Circle. Note: this document requires the Adobe Acrobat Reader

The options open to Alberta's Métis population to achieve self-government are explored in a paper by Denis Wall. 

The Department of Indian and Northern Affairs provides a range of information about the various first nations agreements that have already been signed or are currently under negotiation.

As part of their assertion of self-government, several First Nations in Québec have declared that they cannot be forced to be included in a future sovereign Québec. For example, the Grand Council of the Cree in Québec have published a variety of documents on Quebec separation and how it would affect Cree interests.  In particular, the Cree Nation believes it has just the same right to self-determination as the Québécois and can decide for itself whether to go with Québec. See their detailed examination of the issue in Sovereign Injustice (provided through Archive.org) .

INAC has produced studies of the issues surrounding moving toward sustainable development for Aboriginal communities, especially with respect to their relationship with INAC. 

LEGAL LINKS

You can read the full text of the Supreme Court of Canada's recent rulings on Aboriginal rights. One of its most controversial rulings was on Aboriginal fishing rights in the Maritime provinces.  After its 1999 decision in R. v. Marshall in September 1999 there were a number of violent protests by non-Native fishers.  The Court eventually clarified its positions in a second ruling on the case two months later, stating that it did not mean that Native fishing absolute and could not be regulated by the federal government.  See also the BC Government's collection of landmark cases in aboriginal law.

Other important decisions dealing with Aboriginal issues include:

  • Blueberry River Indian Band v. Canada (Department of Indian Affairs and Northern Development) [1995] 
  • Chippewas of Sarnia Band v. Canada (2000 - Ontario Court of Appeal)
  • Campbell v. B.C. & Nisga'a Nation  (2000) - BC Supreme Court)
  • Delgamuukw v. British Columbia [1997] 
  • Haida Nation v. British Columbia (Minister of Forests) [2004]
  • Mitchell v. Peguis Indian Band [1990] 
  • Native Women's Assn. of Canada v. Canada [1994] 
  • Ontario (Attorney General) v. Bemlar Island Foundation [1991] 
  • R. v. Coté [1996] 
  • R. v. Pamajewon [1996] 
  • R. v. Adams [1996] 
  • R. v. Badger [1996] 
  • R. v. Marshall; R. v. Bernard [2005]
  • R. v. N.T.C. Smokehouse Ltd. [1995] 
  • R. v. Van der Peet [1995] 
  • R. v. Nikal [1995] 
  • R. v. Howard [1994] 
  • R. v. Sioui [1990] 
  • R. v. Sparrow [1990]

     

    Legislation:

    Aboriginal Law and Legislation Online includes links to the full text of recent Aboriginal cases from the Supreme Court of Canada. 

    Aboriginal Policing issues are dealt with at a site run by the federal solicitor general. 

    Aboriginal Rights Sections in the Constitution Act, 1982

    Constitution Amendment Proclamation, 1983

    The Constitution of the Iroquois Nations Confederacy

    Federal legislation relevant to Aboriginal concerns - from Indian and Northern Affairs 

    Henderson's Annotated Indian Act  Note: this is a LARGE file! 

    Indian Act - in both text and folio format; includes regulations under the Act 

    The Royal Proclamation, 1763

    University of Saskatchewan Native Law Centre

     

    TREATIES

    Historic Indian Treaties - Information Sheet from INAC 

    The Jay Treaty of 1794

    Maps of Selected Canadian Indian Treaties  Note: large graphics 

    The 1998 Nisga'a Treaty has generated considerable controversy in British Columbia. The B.C. government provides useful information in a variety of the side agreements and fact sheets on the treaty; for more current updates, consult the implementation reports.  The Liberal Party strongly opposed the treaty when in Opposition and challenged its constitutionality in court. However, the B.C. Supreme Court ruled against the BC Liberal Party's court challenge to the Treaty in July 2000. 

    Numbered Treaties on-line from Indian and Northern Affairs: 


    Indian and Northern Affairs provides an interesting collection of treaty texts, guides and maps.

    LINKS TO ABORIGINAL ORGANIZATIONS

    Aboriginal Youth Network

    Assembly of First Nations

    Assembly of Manitoba Chiefs

    BC Aboriginal Rights Coalition

    BC First Nations

    Congress of Aboriginal Peoples

    Federation of Saskatchewan Indian Nations

    Innu Nation

    Inuit Tapiriit Kanatami (formerly the Inuit Tapirisat of Canada )

    Metis Resource Centre 

    Native Women's Association of Canada

    Union of British Columbia Indian Chiefs

    Treaty 7 Tribal Council

    Turtle Island

    The Village of First Nations

     

    GOVERNMENT DEPARTMENTS DEALING WITH ABORIGINAL AFFAIRS

    Alberta Aboriginal Affairs and Northern Development

    BC Ministry of Aboriginal Relations and Reconciliation

    British Columbia Treaty Commission

    Indian and Northern Affairs Canada

    Manitoba - Aboriginal & Northern Affairs

    New Brunswick Aboriginal Affairs Secretariat

    Nova Scotia Aboriginal Affairs

    Ontario Native Affairs Secretariat

    Saskatchewan Government Relations and Aboriginal Affairs

    Que. Secrétariat aux affaires autochtones

    Yukon Executive Council

     

    LINKS TO LINKS

    Aboriginal Canada Portal

    Aboriginal Connections

    Bill's Aboriginal Links

    First Nations Periodical Index


    You can find more information related to Aboriginal issues in other sections of Nelson's Canadian Politics on the Web: 

    Civil Rights

    Constitution

    Federalism

    Legal System: Courts and Legislation

    Quebec and National Unity